The Courage They Had, Briefly
January 12, 1981. A new soap opera premieres on ABC, an oil family in Denver, a patriarch about to remarry, all the ingredients of an hour meant to be by Tuesday. Except the show does something nobody asked it to do. It gives the patriarch a son, Steven Carrington, and it makes that son gay, not as a punchline, not as a scandal to be resolved by episode’s end, but as a fact he carries into every room he enters. Blake cannot look at it directly. The show does.
Eight years earlier, America had already been given the test run. An American Family arrives on PBS in 1973, a documentary series meant to simply observe a household in Santa Barbara, and partway through the filming the eldest son, Lance Loud, comes out on camera, unplanned, unscripted, entirely himself. He is flamboyant where Steven will later be careful, unashamed where Steven will later be tormented, and ten million people watch anyway. The country does not look away. It argues, it debates, it takes sides on the Louds around dinner tables for months, but it watches, Thursday after Thursday, all the way to the end. By the time Dynasty premieres in 1981, the proof already exists. America was ready to see this. Steven Carrington did not need to be invented cautiously. He was invented cautiously anyway.
This is, by any honest measure, a startling piece of bravery for the year it happens. Billy Crystal’s character on Soap has already tested the water for comedy, but Dynasty asks something harder of its audience, that they sit with a drama, not a joke, and let a leading man’s sexuality be a source of gravity rather than relief. Steven is not there to lighten a scene. He is there to complicate one. For a moment, the network trusted its audience with that complication.
Then February arrives, and March, and the show blinks. Ted Dinard, Steven’s lover, dies in episode thirteen, shoved by Blake into a fireplace hearth, and the bravery that opened the series spends the rest of its run in retreat. Steven marries Sammy Jo. Steven marries Claudia. The writers hand him wife after wife like a man being handed sandbags, weighting him back down into a shape the network can live with. Al Corley says as much on his way out the door in 1982, that Steven has stopped being allowed to have any fun, any humor, any steadiness in who he is. The courage that opened the series does not evolve. It collapses.
Picture the version that does not collapse. Ted lives past episode thirteen. The show that had the nerve to introduce him has the nerve to keep him, and Steven’s story becomes not a pendulum swinging between women assigned to prove something, but a life, difficult and ordinary in the ways lives are, allowed to simply continue on screen the way Blake and Krystle’s continues, the way Fallon’s continues. The premiere’s dare gets a second act instead of an apology.
That version of Dynasty is not a softer show. It is a more finished one. The audacity that made the pilot a sensation was never really about the shock of a gay character existing, it was about the promise that television might finally treat one as fully as it treated everyone else. A story that kept that promise across eight seasons, rather than making it once and spending the rest of its run walking it back, would not have diluted the show’s reputation for daring. It would have been the thing the show was actually remembered for.
Instead the record shows a single bold opening move, followed by years of the network deciding that bravery was a pilot episode expense, not a running cost. The tragedy of the real Dynasty is not that it made Steven gay. It is that having made him so, it could never again find the nerve of its own premiere.
— Behan